Thursday, May 21, 2009

Finals and other reflections

For the last week or so, I've been bogged down in finals. Most people know the experience as students, but it is no less crazy for faculty. Other than writing assignments and tests (multiple choice questions take forever to write), there's the onslaught of student emails, requests for office hours (after they are over for the semester), late papers, incompletes from previous semesters, etc. Meanwhile, there's the distinct feeling that you are working way too hard and that you should be spending the time on your own research (the only thing that you get credit for in academia--teaching counts for nothing when it comes to job evaluations, promotions and most hiring). So, Mayle definitely has not had first place in my life recently.

Still, I did get the Tati belt (for $100 from Shopbop although I am going to contact them for a price adjustment as two days later, it went down to $75). Right now, I am so broke--read, so in credit card debt--from the Mayle sample sale, so I really can't be spending. But the belt is lovely--along with Braque, one of my favorite Mayle belts ever. Unlike Braque, it fits more than just S waists (I'm small there, but I am not a size 2-4) and the leather is so lovely that it looks like it will last for years and wear well. It will also add some versatility to some of my other Mayle pieces. Looking back on the old lookbooks, belts are a huge part of Mayle's styling, sometimes to toughen up a pretty dress, which Tati will do well. So, in the absence of new items, I can play around with what I already have. Financially, that's probably wise too as I have overstretched myself recently.

In what little free time I had the last week, I became obsessed with checking out ebay. Not for items for me--nobody was selling much above a size 4--again, probably just as well for my poor credit card. But I did notice that older items were being flushed out, probably due to the perception now is the time to sell high and cash out before people either move on to other designers, forget Mayle or realize they overspent at the sample sale and the numerous sales/re-editions/auctions that preceded it. I've seen items I covet appear--the Clothilde in Cassis for one--but only in sizes that won't work for me. I've also seen ludicrous prices asked--and not received--for more mundane, dated or unremarkable items--so there does seem to be some sanity there.

As it is that time of year to reflect, I can say how proud I am of some of my students. I am also proud that my teaching helped them--it may not count for anything in my profession but I can't perform my job if I don't think students matter.

It's the end of another academic year. I look back upon this one as another dud: I did not get the tenure track job I was searching for (although this is not something that was my fault--the market, the bizarre trends in my field and pure bad luck all played a part and I don't think there was anything else I could have done).

I am also bitterly disappointed/devastated that another year has passed and I did not get pregnant. A year ago, just as finals were ending, a dear friend announced her accidental pregnancy. I am not proud of my response--it was anger and deep sadness--I felt she had stolen my dream (she had deep ambivalence about becoming a mother and it was never something on her agenda). To console myself, I told myself I would be a mother within a year. Well that year has passed. I currently have 8 pregnant friends and acquaintances and am supposed to go to yet another shower next Saturday but one of my best friends has advised me to protect myself and not go. It's just so hard to keep buying baby items for other people, smile, give my gift and celebrate when it looks like my turn will never come.

I'm beginning to wonder why I torture myself by continuing to try, especially as many people--including the doctors at Columbia-are cold, negative and uncaring. Trying to have a baby seems like an expensive but academic exercise--take temperature every morning, chart, wear OV watch, test, test, test, rearrange schedules, wait, hope, cry. It's so tough to go along this route and anybody who asks for help from the medical establishment is dismissed with cold statistics from doctors who only care about their liability insurance, being sued and their IVF success rates.

I used to think the big divides in this culture were class (race in many ways is submerged and embedded in class stratification which then perpetuates so much racial difference), age (as we know, the vital years are short and older people, especially women, become invisible and unwanted in the workforce), and disability. All are unspoken and unrepresented. But I'd now add fertility. Having seen the inside of a fertility clinic, I saw all demographics, races and classes of women, none of them making eye contact with each other. Some pretended to be absorbed in work, blackberries or magazine articles, others stared into space. But the sense of a shared bond that nobody could admit to permeated the air, along with a profound sadness that comes with facing fears in an institution that won't give you any hope, lest it be false and they get sued. I wanted these women to be bonding, to hear a note of conversation, confession, even to acknowledge each other. But the atmosphere was so off-putting that I prayed I'd never have to return and face the cold receptionists and the distanced doctors (the nurses were the only ones there to retain their humanity and humor).

I can accept the legal and professional dictats that turn doctors into these cold ciphers of humanity. I've become immune to many students' desperate pleas for grade changes or to be admitted into classes that are so full that there are no more seats left. I understand their pain, the consequences but can't do anything and turn off. Obviously, the stakes are bigger for doctors and I know that they are trained to be distant. But with something like fertility (as with so many illnesses), there is a mind-body equation to consider, so the coldness I faced seems to make things worse, not better. I only wonder how horrible the medical establishment is for those with terminal diseases. I hope I never have to find out. But I now understand why people opt for alternative medicine--it may not necessarily cure you, but you are treated with hope, by people who seem to value you and your dreams. Even if it is a scam, people who are scared, lonely and in despair need to be treated with compassion, not clinically. What I have seen of the medical establishment here makes me very angry.

I've also found out that friends with children cannot believe you are really struggling to conceive--after a point, it just becomes boring to them and they blame you--it has to be your fault, after all. It was so easy for them. Also, you can't participate in the same way--no babysitting to share, the conversation isn't around children (or, rather, it's around their child's milestones and rituals, but your issues--whether to do with fertility or not--are dismissed). Not all my friends are like this--some are deeply compassionate and rounded individuals who welcome a break to discuss politics, academe, fashion, pop culture, art, history and science--but others have started to make it clear that this is clearly my fault and they don't care to hear any more about it.

So, I guess I made up for my lack of posts with this one. With summer school about to start, I have to make some choices as to how to change my life. I'm going to jump back into the Columbia clinic and try for a baby, but my reservations about the atmosphere of the place remain. If I had the opportunity to go elsewhere, I certainly would. I wish I was rich enough to go somewhere where they would treat me--and the others in my situation--with more compassion than sterility--after all, that's an experience we all know far too well. And if anybody can be tough on me, it's me. I don't need to pay somebody else to do that job.

17 comments:

joyce said...

i can definitely sympathize with your emotions about school right now. for me, the end of the spring semester always brings mixed feelings. i know that i've accomplished a lot -- teaching courses, advising independent projects, etc. -- but i always feel like i didn't do enough to further "my own" work.

as for the fertility issue, i can only imagine your frustration, moya. between a health care system that doesn't make sense and a socio-cultural construction of motherhood that is incredibly problematic, it's no wonder you feel as you do.

but look at what you've done a few short months! with this blog, you've created a community of interesting, talented women who feel free to share their interests. i know i look forward to each of your posts and each comment that follows.

Moya said...

Thank you, Joyce. I appreciate your wonderful reply and thank you for your support.

Marti said...

Moya, I can only imagine how hurt and frustrated you are at hearing all the baby news. I have severl friends going though what you and your husband are and I know how painful (emotionally and physically) this situation is. Hopefully with some time off you will have the opportunity to keep trying and have a positive outcome.

Moya said...

Thank you so much Marti. It's also all the tougher because it is such an isolating issue. Plus it makes you feel like a total failure as a person--something I fight successfully most of the time!

joyce said...

btw, i wrote to the ebay seller regarding her clothilde blouse. she has taken down the piece b/c someone offered her $700 for it (and it wasn't even new/unworn)! can you believe that? insane.

Moya said...

Wow. I figured it was a BIN, but I imagined somebody offered about $400. Net-a-porter in England had one last year on sale for about $250 and it took forever to sell. I'd have bought it but it was a 6 and I have no idea how Clothilde fits. I guess if there are people out there with that kind of money to burn, auctions are going to be insane. I love it but no top is worth $700.

Cindy said...

Moya, take heart, you're reaching out to so many different people through your teaching and clearly, through this blog. And you will be a mother one day soon, I'm sure of it - if you make it a goal, it will be. I'm rooting for you.

Ignore the haters. So many new gen-x mothers seem to think that their births are so uniquely miraculous - but seriously, it's just reproduction. They have no right to make such negative passing judgements on childless adults. It's intolerable.

Moya said...

Thank you, Cindy. You put things into perspective too--I've had friends make me feel deficient as a human because I haven't had a child and then use that to preach at me, pointing to the ways I fail as a human. It obviously doesn't help. It is just reproduction, as you say and it is intolerable.

And sometime we'll have to have a discussion about the medical process and the way it voids compassion. My experiences have made me very interested in this topic.

UM said...

Hi Moya, it sounds like you need to find a more patient friendly practice. I am sorry the doctors are so cold. Sometimes a freestanding fertility center is more patient friendly than a university center. I say this sadly since I am a physician at a university hospital. We are not trained to be distant. However, the joy of medicine is really being lost as we spend so much more time dealing with insurance companies and other regulations than actually taking care of patients. Also, 95% of my patients are wonderful nice people; however it is the 5% who are nasty that take up way more of our time and lead to alot of burnout and unhappiness among physicians. There are alot of very warm, caring fertility specialists out there, so don't feel obliged to stick with the same place. Best wishes and I know you will be a mom in Mayle very soon. I will ask my colleagues in NY who they recommend and I can forward it to you if you like. my email umamah1@yahoo.com

Cindy said...

UM, you are so sweet! I am so glad you put that out there! BTW, Moya, I'm working on the regulatory aspect to ensure that our patients have a better understanding of their fertility options before engaging in fertility-robbing treatments, and I do have to say that listening to comments of an administrator at a very prominent NYC metro fertility clinic at a university hospital really reflect what UM is saying. This clinic spends so much of their money/energy defensively and this directly affects how you are treated. I think you should look into freestanding facilities as UM suggests, mostly because they are more consumer-oriented rather than patient-oriented.

Moya said...

Uma--thank you so much. I will contact you. I had opted for Columbia partly for health insurance reasons (my current insurer covers 75% of IVF there) and because I thought it would be a good place given that it is a research institute. My mum is a nurse and I understand why you can't take on patients' emotional issues--she always talked about the first and only time she over-invested in a patient. As a student nurse, she really bonded with a young patient who had been in a motorcycle accident. He died and she was devastated and realized you have to put up boundaries.

I was, however, distressed that when I met with a fertility specialist/RE that she was so cold. She gave me raw, depressing stats, explained why they were so bad (after 30-35 egg quality declines, etc.) She told me many older mothers in the news--celebrities and the like--probably used donated eggs and then lied about it. I left feeling like a failure. I also don't think she took into account that many of her clients had researched everything extensively before they stepped in the clinic.

I also found the desk staff to be inept--I was sent to the wrong place for blood tests, yelled at when I asked questions and treated dismissively as they ate and conducted personal cellphone conversations. All in all, I was not impressed.

That said--there are amazing doctors there, but I have heard that Columbia's success rates are not the highest in NYC. I'd love to discuss this further and *really* appreciate your feedback and help.

Cindy, thank you for your comments. I'm interested in the term fertility robbing--can you say more?

Moya said...

I should also mention that it was clear that the doctor I saw was giving a speech she'd given many times (complete with illustrations). I felt like I'd gone to get help only to be told all the reasons I could fail to get pregnant--and thus not sue the clinic if I spent tens of thousands of dollars and left empty-handed.

UM said...

As a side note Metier got their box of mayle. I ended up getting the travel bag, vanya in jaquard, nieves with flamingo, and the rio plata trimmed black lotus michaela. I wasn't planning on getting the last piece but it was my favorite one. The top is black lotus the bottom Is solid black and the trim is rio plata. It is very soft and feminine.

UM said...

They also got astrid in violet and leopard jackets and one shijo size 4. 4159895395 if you are interested. Sorry Moya it does seem like an awkward post but just wanted to let you all know if you are interested.

Christina said...

Don't blame yourself. Not all women are ready in their 20s to early 30s when our bodies are at their prime. How do you know it would have been easier for you when you were younger? There are no guarantees when it comes to fertility, no matter what age you are. At the risk of sounding selfish, I'm not prepared emotionally and financially for that kind of responsibility, even at 30! My professional life is not even close to what I expected it to be so that has been a struggle and I feel like I'm getting nowhere. A lot of women put their career first and there's nothing wrong with that. Instead of reflecting on what you don't have, look at the bigger picture and be thankful for what you are blessed with. You have Evan, a job, an amazing career, loving friends and family. Seriously, stop being so hard on yourself!!!!

I agree with Cindy. It's just reproduction. It's blown out of proportion sometimes. Luckily, there are other options out there like surrogacy or adoption. May I suggest volunteering this summer at an adoption agency or an orphanage. I think it will help you feel less isolated with this issue and give you hope. There are a lot of children out there who need love. Don't listen to those friends who say you are a failure as a human. I would question if those are true friends!? Besides, not everyone can conceive as easily as others.

I sincerely wish you the best and know that you will be an amazing mom someday.

erica said...

i know nothing about fertility clinics, but it does sound like you might be better off at a different place. it's so sad that you're basically told to expect failure right off the bat.

i don't think you're hoping for the impossible. you should be treated with dignity and respect. you're right that the mind-body connection is incredibly important, especially when it comes to conceiving and carrying a pregnancy successfully. i hope that this summer can give you the space to recover from a tough year.

lorochills said...

moya-to hear your side of the fertility issue really opens my eyes...i mean i thought people with the same interest usually tend to bond together rather than ignore one another...i wish you could go to another clinic and i wish the doctors would be more compassionate...i feel that people do not have a right to judge you and should be trying their very hardest to serve their patients
also in regards to the baby showers maybe you could just take a break from the showers...not sure if this is possible but between school and life sometimes you just need a little break...